being a student, Dream

On Embracing Our Stereotypes – A Post from A Student

Every year we finish our year with the This I Believe assignment.  Every year I am floored by their messages of hope, of figuring out right from wrong, of creating a world where kids feel accepted, engaged, and loved.  While many of them are incredible, I asked one student if I could share what they wrote.  

Note:  I did not do a good job explaining why I asked this child to share their writing publicly.  To me, hearing these words, caused immense sadness.  It was a metaphorical slap to once again remember how much power we have as teachers, as adults, to confine the view that students have of themselves.  While people have debated in the comments, I know what the intent of the student was.   She chose to rise above the stereotypes thrust upon her, which I told her made me sad.  No child should have to fight stereotypes in this way.  She disagreed with me, but I still wanted to post the speech because it really made me think deeply about things I still have to do better.  Thank you to those who have engaged in the debate.

Have you ever felt that because you’re different from someone, that you somehow needed to prove yourself or make someone think a certain way? That you had a stereotype that was so untrue you almost could laugh. Stereotypes. We all know them. Most of your childhoods we’ve grown up believing them. People who wear glasses are… People who are blonde are… People who are tall play… people who are popular are…  Stereotypes are bad. You shouldn’t say them, use them, or even think them. We need to do something about them. At least that’s what many of you probably think. Nope, not me. I believe stereotypes are good! They make you your best self, at least from my experiences.

There is a moment I think of whenever I say my “This I believe” sentence. I remember this moment perfectly, it wasn’t  the moment I realized stereotyping is real, I already had seen it and even had it happen to me. Instead, what I really realized was that people don’t mean to do this they just do it without realizing what they are doing. I was in the 5th grade and it was the first week of school. I’d barely talked to the teacher the past day and she barely knew me at the time. We were working on some project talking about how we thought our year would go. I was writing and writing until my hand hurt I was so excited about the year. I walked up to the teacher to ask if I could go to the bathroom. She was typing on her computer. I barely got the first syllable out when she turned around so fast it was like she was expecting me to do something and she needed to watch for it. She sat up in a more authoritative position and folded her arms and did that mean “what do you want” teacher face that almost all teachers do and said, “What?!”. I went ahead and asked her if I could go to the restroom, but as I was talking something weird happened. Her position became more relaxed and she started to unfold her arms and look less cross. Her eyes also became very wide and then normal and kinder. You would only notice this if you were watching closely or used to this happening. And she said in a much kinder way than before. “ Of course you can honey it’s right around there, Do you know where it is?” Well, that was weird I thought as I walked to the bathroom. I stayed in there for probably longer than I had to, just looking in the mirror and trying to figure out what just happened. “Was it what I was wearing?” “Had she heard I was bad!?”

It was as if just by hearing me talk no different than how I normally talk or how anyone else talks she thought higher of me and then after I used manners like thank you she was even more surprised. So I thought if that made her think higher of me then where was I on the scale before? But it was okay, I knew what she was thinking. She was expecting me to talk “ghetto” or say something rude or be loud because those are her experiences I guess.

The thing is, no one remembers the polite, quiet, hard working black kids.

Oh no, they remember the loud obnoxious ones who are rude, disrespectful, talk back and cuss at them.  Those experiences stick in your head. Not the good ones.  At first, when I realized this, I was angry. I wanted to go in there and accuse her of being mean or a bad teacher. I wanted to judge her on something, see how it made her feel. I thought about that pretty much all day. About what “thing” or stereotype I wanted to give her.

And I thought about it while sitting at lunch, Waiting for my bus. Even when I was home. And I forgave her. She probably didn’t do it on purpose and besides, I barely knew her yet anyway. But when I went back to school the next week, I made sure no one would ever have that realization again. In every class I sat up straighter, so straight it would probably be parallel to a board. I made sure without fail I always said please, thank you, May I, etc. I made sure my work is always in on time and always my best. I was kind to everyone and never scowled or looked angry. Close to the third week of school, we started to get homework which I made sure I did. When the teacher went around to collect it, she looked impressed that I had mine out and done and did that thing where you purse your lips and nod sort of. She didn’t do that to anyone else. Umm…. was I not supposed to have it done?

I didn’t miss one assignment that year.  Every stereotype I made sure I proved that stereotype wrong. Such as black kids being rude. I was never mean and/or rude to anyone in my class. Or that black kid who would all talk “ghetto” and have bad English. I made sure whenever I talked it was never with much slang or used words like ain’t but with respectable english. And my tone was always quieter than most very much so. (That actually took me awhile to get out of because, I became very quiet that year and I got used to it. I had to work myself back out of my shell). Whenever you have a stereotype that is not true, you work hard to prove someone wrong. You are your best self too! And most of all you show what you want to. So that people see what you really are not just what they want.

I’m used to this now. I no longer spend hours thinking about these things. I don’t get mad or sad anymore  either. But sometimes we are judged, we are judged all the time actually. And I speak from experience, it doesn’t matter if it’s the clerk’s eyes on you in a store like every single second or the way you talk. What you wear,  how you look, if you wear glasses or not. Your stereotype makes you better by giving you motivation to change it or change what people think when they first see you.  It’s very easy to form a stereotype. Heck, we do it all the time. So if you come across someone who has a completely untrue stereotype of you, don’t dwell on it. Make sure you change their minds. Make sure they remember how you proved them wrong. That’s why stereotypes help you. It makes you think more, It makes you present yourself the way you really want to be seen like. It makes you think about every decision more carefully and think “Is this what I really want to do?” It makes sure that you make yourself stick out from the crowd and prove your stereotype wrong and that’s what makes you your best self. I believe  stereotypes make you your best self.


8 thoughts on “On Embracing Our Stereotypes – A Post from A Student”

  1. This made me very sad. His/Her motivation to do well should not have stemmed from a desire to prove the stereotype wrong. He/she was already their best self.

  2. My sentiments exactly mw. I am so sad for this kid. He/she has to live in a society where he/she is judged so harshly, they spend all their time trying to prove to people that they are not what people believe they are.My heart bleeds for this child.:(

  3. I agree to disagree. We live in a world all around us that stereotypes daily. If it is not the color of your skin, it is by your grammar, your socioeconomic status. No need to feel sad for the child who gets it and aware of their surroundings. Be happy they are battling these issues that exist in our of unfair world positively. People always say, “children are okay they bounce back”. I do not care for this saying. Because as adults we are to be an example daily in our profession of teaching. We are to filled with empathy and compassion to put our thought process aside to learn from our students of what they are struggling with inside. I have seen so much within my profession and I can truly see why this student felt the way they felt. What happens each year if a student has referrals, sometimes for stupid situations, and begin to be labeled. I have to had to stop sitting my teacher lounges because I personally get sick of hearing all the negative talk. I never hear anything good said about any students of how terrible they are. After awhile they’ll say it in front of other students then it trickles down to staff of what they are not doing and it goes on and on.
    If you are not careful it might just affect you. I was determined to stay clear because I am not just a parent as well but these are some other parents children. I always reflect on if this was my child even in the most difficult situations. Stay blessed everyone and positive. Times are changing but that doesn’t mean we change our WHY of becoming the fabulous teachers we are.

  4. Excuse the typo and errors. Did not read over. Let’s see if I’m stereotyped for the errors. 🙂

  5. This piece is disturbingly sad, and a study on how young respectability politics are thrust on black children. I can’t believe any adult would encourage such toxic thought in a minor. It’s not “real world”. That child will be no less stereotyped because he is polite or well mannered. Publishing this piece simply rewards the idea that black children should bend over backwards to meet appease whiteness and make non-blac people feel comfortable with their meet existence. This may not have been performative behavior for This child (though his wording suggests that it us), but the very fact that he initially felt something wrong with him, and he intentionally aimed to right it for others comfort suggest a serious problem. This is in no way positive or acceptable. Look at it this way, if you had a trans student who felt your disapproval at just their speaking to you, so they spent the rest of their life performing cis behavior to appease yoo (even if much of it was natural) would that be okay? God, I hope you said no.

    1. Thank you for your comment, I apologize for my intentions not being clear in why I published this piece. I agree with what you said; the reason I published this piece is because I wanted others to have a chance of reacting to it; with surprise, anger, and also a pause to think about how we, adults/teachers, are pushing children into boxes that then lead them to feel like they have to overcome the stereotypes that we have placed on them.

      1. I want to believe that, I do, but you can understand my reservations when you skipped correcting the comments that praise this child’s sad situation, and come down and address me instead. Guiding those who misunderstand and are in a place to perpetuate such ignorance would seem a more valuable use of time than apologizing to me, a woman who clearly already sees the error in this thought process. Apologies are appreciated, but not needed; action and clarification are.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s