Yet as the rhetoric gets more cutthroat and the divide grows, this mentality of us versus them has formed and cemented itself into too many educational debates. No longer are teachers united, rather it becomes veterans versus new, tech users vs non-tech users, always a split, always two sides, never just one united front. And we teachers buy into it as well. If one teacher is heralded for doing something good, other teachers get upset because then they must be doing something wrong. If a school is highlighted as working well, then other schools within the district must be performing poorly. Rather than view success of one as success for all, it becomes just that; success for one and failure for everyone else.
This epidemic of negativity must stop. We are tearing each other apart, trying to climb to the top, vying for the same spotlight. But that is not what teaching is about, we teach our students that we are only as strong as the weakest performance, and that we must celebrate everyone. And yet, somewhere that message is lost. The public may want us split, because then it is easier to create “reform” and yet now is the time we must band together. We must relearn to celebrate successes and not be afraid to share them. It is time for people to speak up when something incredible happens in their classroom or in their school, and it is time for everyone else to celebrate it, not tear it down. This isn’t me versus you, it’s all of us together.
I've seen what you talk about in the last paragraph firsthand. It's sad. If we are all working for the good of our students, we should all be able to put our egos aside and learn from each other the great things we all do.
So true, Pernille. "We're in this together," should be our motto. It's not about praise or blame, but rather about learning together. My last blogpost called "No Harm" touched on these ideas. BTW, enjoying your blog immensely.
Pernille, what you are describing in education is unfortunately happening throughout our society. There will always be disagreements among people, but the level of seeming hatred in multiple areas of our society is truly disturbing to me. I hope that we can join together as educators to encourage each other to strive for our best as we work with our students.
I think if we all act as rolemodels and band together it will spread. e can all get so caught up in the negativity – trust me in Wisconsin it is particularly easy – and yet we have to continue to fight for all of us.